Skip to content
Entertainment & Biography

Are Garrett and Johnna Still Together? Current Status and Relationship History

In this article

No, Garrett Miller and Johnna DiGrigoli are not still together. The couple, who rose to fame during the inaugural season of WE tv’s Love After Lockup, ended their relationship shortly after filming concluded in 2018. As of 2026, both have moved on significantly, with Garrett being married and Johnna pursuing a life away from the reality TV spotlight.

The Origins of Garrett and Johnna’s Relationship

To understand why Garrett and Johnna are no longer together, one must look back at the foundation of their relationship, which was atypical from the start. Johnna DiGrigoli and Garrett Miller began their journey while Garrett was serving a seven-year prison sentence for several charges, including grand theft and burglary.

Johnna, who lived in Florida at the time, became a central figure in the first season of Love After Lockup because of her intense dedication to Garrett. Having waited for the majority of his sentence, she had planned their entire post-prison life before he even stepped foot outside the correctional facility. This dynamic created a "waiting game" narrative that resonated with millions of viewers, making them one of the most talked-about couples in the franchise's history.

The Power Dynamics of Incarceration

The relationship was defined by a significant power imbalance that often occurs when one partner is incarcerated. While Garrett was behind bars, Johnna held the reins of their shared future. She managed the finances, chose their housing, and set the expectations for his behavior upon release. This "control" was a major plot point throughout Season 1, as Johnna’s desire for a traditional commitment—specifically an engagement and marriage—clashed with Garrett’s newfound desire for freedom and exploration.

Why Did Garrett and Johnna Break Up?

The dissolution of Garrett and Johnna’s relationship was neither sudden nor entirely unexpected for those watching the show. Once Garrett was released, the reality of living together proved to be vastly different from the romanticized version of the relationship they had maintained through letters and glass partitions.

The Conflict of Expectations

Johnna’s primary goal was stability. After waiting seven years, she expected Garrett to transition immediately into the role of a devoted husband and provider. However, Garrett, who had spent a significant portion of his youth behind bars, was eager to experience everything he had missed. This fundamental mismatch in life stages was the primary catalyst for their split.

Garrett’s behavior post-release was often criticized by fans of the show. He was seen as being more interested in partying and social media attention than in building a quiet life with Johnna. On the other hand, Johnna’s "high-intensity" personality and her admitted tendency to micromanage Garrett’s life created a stifling environment for a man who had just regained his autonomy.

The Catalyst: Infidelity Allegations and Nelly

Shortly after the season finished airing, it became clear that the two had parted ways. The breakup was messy and played out partially over social media. Garrett quickly went public with a new girlfriend, Nelly (Nely) G, which led to widespread speculation regarding when exactly their relationship began. Johnna hinted that Garrett had been unfaithful or, at the very least, had checked out of their relationship emotionally long before the official breakup.

Are The Bachelorette's Becca and Garrett Still Together? | POPSUGAR ...
Are The Bachelorette's Becca and Garrett Still Together? | POPSUGAR ...

Where is Garrett Miller in 2026?

As of 2026, Garrett Miller has completely reinvented his life, distancing himself from his reality TV past while maintaining a presence on social media. His life today is a stark contrast to the volatile days seen on Season 1 of Love After Lockup.

Marriage and Family

The most significant development in Garrett’s life post-Johnna is his marriage to Nelly. The couple remained together for several years before officially tying the knot in late 2022. Their relationship appears to be stable, far removed from the drama that defined his time with Johnna.

Garrett and Nelly have also expanded their family. The couple welcomed a son, and Garrett’s social media accounts often feature glimpses of his life as a father and husband. This transition into a domestic, family-oriented lifestyle suggests that his resistance to commitment during his time with Johnna may have been more about the specific person and the circumstances rather than a general aversion to settling down.

Professional Pursuits

Professionally, Garrett has leveraged his fitness and construction background. In the years following the show, he focused on personal training and various trades. By 2026, he has established a steady career that prioritizes his family’s privacy over the "clout-chasing" behavior sometimes seen in former reality stars. While he occasionally engages with fans of the show, he does not appear interested in returning to the Love After Lockup franchise or pursuing a career in entertainment.

Where is Johnna DiGrigoli in 2026?

Johnna DiGrigoli has also undergone a massive transformation since her time on television. Known for her wit and her ability to laugh at her own "crazy girlfriend" edit, Johnna has moved on from the heartbreak of 2018 to build a successful independent life.

Relocation to Texas

One of Johnna’s first major moves after the breakup was leaving Florida. She relocated to Austin, Texas, a move she documented as a fresh start. The change in scenery allowed her to escape the local notoriety associated with the show and Garrett’s family. In Austin, she built a new social circle and pursued career opportunities in marketing and social media management.

Her Views on Reality TV and Growth

In the years since the show, Johnna has been remarkably transparent about her experience. She has often spoken about how the "edit" of the show emphasized her most anxious moments while ignoring the context of Garrett’s behavior. However, she has also taken accountability for her actions, admitting that she was in a different headspace at 25 than she is now.

In 2026, Johnna is often cited as one of the "success stories" of the franchise, not because she stayed with her partner, but because she found her own identity outside of the relationship. She maintains a following on social media where she shares updates about her life, her dog, and her professional achievements, rarely mentioning Garrett or the show unless asked by fans for a "blast from the past."

Comparison of Life Post-Breakup

The following table outlines the divergent paths Garrett and Johnna have taken since their split after Love After Lockup Season 1.

Feature Garrett Miller (2026) Johnna DiGrigoli (2026)
Relationship Status Married to Nelly (Nely) Single / Private
Children Has a son with Nelly No children
Primary Location Florida Texas (Austin)
Public Image Family-man, Fitness-oriented Independent, Career-focused
View of the Show Largely moved on; rarely discusses it Analytical; uses platform for transparency
Current Career Construction and Personal Training Marketing and Social Media

The Impact of "Love After Lockup" on Their Lives

The legacy of Garrett and Johnna is significant within the reality TV landscape. As part of the first season, they were the "blueprint" for the "long-suffering partner vs. the restless parolee" archetype. Their story highlighted the systemic issues that many couples face when reintegrating into society after a long prison sentence.

The "Prisoner’s Dilemma" in Relationships

Sociologists and relationship experts often point to couples like Garrett and Johnna when discussing the "re-entry shock" of former inmates. For Garrett, the world had changed in seven years. The pressure to immediately conform to Johnna's domestic expectations was a significant psychological burden. For Johnna, the years of emotional and financial investment created a "sunk cost" fallacy, where she felt she must make the relationship work because of how much she had sacrificed.

The Role of Social Media

Unlike later seasons of the show where couples often try to stay together for "brand" purposes or to secure spots on spin-offs like Life After Lockup, Garrett and Johnna’s split was visceral and final. They did not attempt to manufacture a reconciliation for the cameras. This authenticity is part of why they remain memorable to fans even in 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Garrett and Johnna ever get back together after the show?

No. Following their initial split shortly after Season 1 finished filming, the two have never officially reconciled. They both moved on to different relationships almost immediately, and there have been no credible reports of a reunion in the years since.

Is Garrett Miller still in legal trouble?

As of 2026, Garrett has maintained a relatively clean record since his release seen on the show. While he had some minor brushes with the law shortly after his release, he appears to have successfully navigated the challenges of parole and has focused on his family and career.

Why did Johnna move to Austin?

Johnna moved to Austin, Texas, primarily for a fresh start. She has stated in interviews and on her social media that she wanted to distance herself from the memories of her relationship with Garrett in Florida and take advantage of the career opportunities available in the Texas tech and marketing hub.

How does Johnna feel about Garrett’s new family?

While she initially expressed hurt and frustration regarding Garrett's quick transition to a new relationship with Nelly, Johnna has matured significantly over the years. In more recent years, she has indicated that she wishes him no ill will and is simply happy to be living her own life independently.

Are Nelly and Garrett still married in 2026?

Yes, Garrett and Nelly are still married. They have been a consistent couple for several years and have focused on raising their son and building a life together away from the drama of the Love After Lockup cameras.

Final Perspective on Garrett and Johnna

The story of Garrett and Johnna is a classic example of how the intense pressure of reality television and the complications of post-prison life can dismantle even the most long-standing commitments. While fans were originally rooted for the couple that had endured a seven-year separation, the reality of their incompatibility became impossible to ignore once they were finally in the same room.

By 2026, it is clear that the breakup was the best outcome for both parties. Garrett found the family life he seemingly wasn't ready for with Johnna, and Johnna found the independence and self-worth that had been overshadowed by her role as a "prison girlfriend." Their journey serves as a reminder that some relationships are meant to be a chapter rather than the whole book.

For those looking to follow their current lives, both maintain active but separate digital footprints. While they will always be linked by their shared history on WE tv, they have successfully moved on to become entirely different people than the ones viewers met nearly a decade ago.