Skip to content
Entertainment & Biography

The Definitive Guide to At the Movies Co-Hosts: From Siskel and Ebert to the Final Balcony

In this article

The most iconic co-hosts of the various television programs titled At the Movies (and its predecessors) were Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert, who defined film criticism for the television age from 1975 until Siskel's death in 1999. They were followed by Richard Roeper, who paired with Ebert, and later by duos including Ben Lyons and Ben Mankiewicz, and finally Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott before the series concluded in 2010.

While several critics occupied the balcony over the decades, the "At the Movies" brand is inextricably linked to the competitive chemistry between Siskel and Ebert, who transformed the solitary act of film criticism into a high-stakes, televised debate. Understanding the lineage of these hosts requires looking at the evolution of the show through its different titles, networks, and eras of critical thought.

The Genesis of the Balcony: Siskel and Ebert (1975–1999)

The concept of two critics debating films began not with a show called At the Movies, but with a local Chicago program titled Opening Soon to a Theater Near You in 1975. The hosts were Gene Siskel of the Chicago Tribune and Roger Ebert of the Chicago Sun-Times. This rivalry was authentic; the two men worked for competing daily newspapers and genuinely disliked each other in the early years.

The PBS Years: Sneak Previews

By 1977, the show was renamed Sneak Previews and picked up by PBS for national distribution. This era established the visual language of the franchise: the darkened theater, the "Dog of the Week" segment, and the fundamental idea that two experts could disagree vehemently while maintaining intellectual respect. Siskel was often seen as the more analytical, sometimes "prickly" critic, while Ebert was perceived as the more populist, emotional writer—though both were deeply steeped in cinematic history.

The Move to Syndication and "At the Movies"

In 1982, Siskel and Ebert left PBS for commercial syndication with Tribune Entertainment. Because PBS owned the title Sneak Previews, the new show was titled At the Movies. It was during this period that the "Thumbs Up" and "Thumbs Down" voting system became a cultural phenomenon. The gesture was eventually trademarked, becoming one of the most powerful marketing tools in Hollywood history.

In 1986, the duo moved to Buena Vista Television (a Disney subsidiary), and the show was renamed Siskel & Ebert & the Movies (later shortened to simply Siskel & Ebert). This iteration remained the gold standard of televised criticism until Gene Siskel’s untimely death in February 1999.

The Transition Era: Finding a New Voice (1999–2000)

Following Siskel's passing, the show faced an existential crisis. For the 1999–2000 season, the program was titled Siskel & Ebert Has a New Partner at the Movies, featuring a rotating carousel of guest critics. This period was essential for testing chemistry and determining if the format could survive without one of its founding pillars.

Notable guest hosts during this transition included:

  • A.O. Scott: Then a rising star at The New York Times.
  • Michael Phillips: A prominent critic for the Chicago Tribune.
  • Janet Maslin: A legendary voice from The New York Times.
  • Richard Roeper: A columnist for the Chicago Sun-Times.

It was Richard Roeper who eventually secured the permanent seat. As a colleague of Ebert's at the Sun-Times, he brought a younger perspective and a sharp, urban wit that provided a fresh dynamic while respecting the established "balcony" traditions.

'The View' Season 26: New Episodes Air in September 2022 with New Co-Hosts
'The View' Season 26: New Episodes Air in September 2022 with New Co-Hosts

The Ebert & Roeper Years (2000–2008)

In 2000, the show was officially rebranded as Ebert & Roeper at the Movies. Richard Roeper faced the daunting task of filling Gene Siskel’s shoes, but he quickly established himself as a formidable critic in his own right. The chemistry changed from the "sibling rivalry" of Siskel and Ebert to a "mentor and protege" or "senior and junior partner" vibe, which eventually leveled out into a balanced partnership.

Health Struggles and the Guest Host Era

In 2006, Roger Ebert underwent surgery for thyroid and salivary gland cancer, which ultimately cost him his ability to speak. Despite this, he remained the show's co-producer and primary creative force. From 2006 to 2008, the show continued with Richard Roeper and a series of guest hosts filling in for Ebert.

During this time, the "Thumbs" were temporarily retired out of respect for Ebert’s inability to participate in the physical gesture on camera, and the show used a "See It," "Rent It," or "Skip It" system. High-profile guests during this period included:

  • Kevin Smith: The filmmaker provided a unique "insider" perspective.
  • Michael Wilbon: Bringing a sports-debate energy to film criticism.
  • Jay Leno: A rare late-night crossover.

In 2008, due to contract disputes and Ebert's ongoing health issues, both Ebert and Roeper left the Disney-produced show, marking the end of the original lineage that had begun in 1975.

The 2008 Reboot: Lyons and Mankiewicz

Disney decided to keep the At the Movies title but completely overhaul the cast and format in September 2008. They hired Ben Lyons (from E! Entertainment) and Ben Mankiewicz (from Turner Classic Movies).

This era is widely regarded as the most controversial in the show's history. Ben Lyons, in particular, was criticized by the traditional film critic community for lacking the academic rigor of his predecessors. Critics felt his reviews were too "fanboy" oriented and lacked depth. Ben Mankiewicz, conversely, was praised for his deep knowledge of classic cinema, but the chemistry between the two was often described as forced or mismatched.

The show attempted to appeal to a younger demographic by incorporating more lifestyle segments and faster editing, but viewership declined as the core audience—who valued the deep-dive analysis of Siskel and Ebert—felt alienated.

The Final Curtain: Phillips and Scott (2009–2010)

Acknowledging the negative reception of the 2008 reboot, Disney made a final attempt to return the show to its roots. In 2009, they replaced Lyons and Mankiewicz with Michael Phillips of the Chicago Tribune and A.O. Scott of The New York Times.

This pairing was a return to the original "newspaper rivalry" format. Both were established, high-brow critics who brought intellectual weight back to the balcony. They restored the "Thumbs Up/Thumbs Down" system (with Ebert's permission) and focused on long-form debate.

Despite critical acclaim for this "return to form," the media landscape had shifted too far. The rise of YouTube critics, Rotten Tomatoes, and the decline of syndicated television made the traditional format difficult to sustain financially. Disney officially cancelled At the Movies in 2010, and the final episode aired on August 14, 2010.

Summary of At the Movies Co-Hosts and Iterations

The following table outlines the primary eras of the show and the critics who occupied the lead roles.

Era Show Title Co-Host A Co-Host B Key Characteristic
1975–1982 Sneak Previews Gene Siskel Roger Ebert Original PBS run; established the "balcony" format.
1982–1986 At the Movies Gene Siskel Roger Ebert First use of the "At the Movies" title under Tribune.
1986–1999 Siskel & Ebert Gene Siskel Roger Ebert The "Golden Age" under Disney; peak cultural impact.
1999–2000 At the Movies Roger Ebert Various Guests Transition period following Gene Siskel's death.
2000–2006 Ebert & Roeper Roger Ebert Richard Roeper Modernization of the show; introduced Richard Roeper.
2006–2008 Ebert & Roeper Richard Roeper Rotating Guests Period of Roger Ebert's illness; many guest critics.
2008–2009 At the Movies Ben Lyons Ben Mankiewicz Attempted "youth-focused" reboot; widely criticized.
2009–2010 At the Movies Michael Phillips A.O. Scott Final "intellectual" era; return to newspaper-style roots.

The Legacy of the Co-Hosts in 2026

As of 2026, the influence of these co-hosts remains a cornerstone of film journalism. While the physical "balcony" set is gone, the format of the "binary review" (Yes/No, Thumbs Up/Down) paved the way for modern aggregators.

The Siskel and Ebert era is now studied in media courses as the pinnacle of "adversarial criticism," where the goal wasn't just to review a movie, but to engage in a dialectic that helped the audience think for themselves. Roger Ebert's later career, specifically his transition to digital writing and his "Great Movies" essays, ensured that the legacy of the show lived on long after the cameras stopped rolling.

Even the later hosts, like A.O. Scott and Michael Phillips, continue to be influential voices in the 2020s, often participating in retrospectives regarding the "At the Movies" impact on the industry. The show proved that film criticism could be entertainment, but its demise also signaled a shift toward the decentralized, algorithmic criticism we see today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who were the original hosts of Sneak Previews before Siskel and Ebert?

Siskel and Ebert were the first hosts of the show that became Sneak Previews. However, after they left for syndication in 1982, Sneak Previews continued on PBS with new hosts: Neal Gabler and Jeffrey Lyons. Gabler was eventually replaced by Michael Medved. This version of the show ran until 1996 but never achieved the same cultural status as the Siskel and Ebert iterations.

Why did Siskel and Ebert use "Thumbs Up" and "Thumbs Down"?

The gesture was a visual shorthand created for television. In the early days of Sneak Previews, they used a system of bells and buzzers, but it felt too gimmicky. The thumb gesture was simple, instantly recognizable, and effectively communicated a binary recommendation. Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel eventually trademarked "Two Thumbs Up" to prevent it from being used by other critics or in unauthorized advertising.

Are any of the former hosts still active in 2026?

Many of the later hosts remain prominent. Richard Roeper continues to review films for the Chicago Sun-Times and various broadcast outlets. A.O. Scott transitioned from film criticism to a broader "critic-at-large" role for The New York Times. Michael Phillips remains a vital voice at the Chicago Tribune. Ben Mankiewicz is still a primary host on Turner Classic Movies (TCM), where he continues to uphold the Mankiewicz family legacy in cinema.

What happened to the "At the Movies" trademark?

The trademark for the title "At the Movies" was held by various entities over the years, primarily Disney/Buena Vista. However, the specific "Two Thumbs Up" trademark was owned by the Siskel and Ebert estates. In recent years, these trademarks have mostly been used for archival purposes, though the "Thumbs" legacy is still licensed for significant film re-releases and prestige marketing.

Did any hosts ever walk off the set during a disagreement?

While Siskel and Ebert were famous for their heated arguments, they were consummate professionals on camera. However, outtakes and "blooper" reels released years later show that behind the scenes, the tension was often palpable. They would frequently argue about the technical phrasing of a "lead-in" or a specific word choice in their partner's review, reflecting the deep competitive streak that made the show work.

Final Recommendation for Fans

If you are looking to revisit the work of these co-hosts in 2026, the best resource is the Ebert Presents archives and the official RogerEbert.com website, which has preserved thousands of reviews and many video segments from the various eras of the show. For those interested in the history of the show's production, the memoir Life Itself by Roger Ebert provides an intimate look at his relationship with Gene Siskel and the evolution of the "balcony" that changed movie-going forever.