Skip to content
Entertainment & Biography

Is There a Second Book to "We Were Liars"? The Complete Series Guide

In this article

Yes, there is a second book connected to We Were Liars. Author E. Lockhart published Family of Liars in May 2022. Rather than a direct chronological sequel following Cadence Sinclair after the events of the original novel, Family of Liars is a prequel set 27 years earlier that reveals the dark secrets of the previous generation of the Sinclair family on Beechwood Island.

Understanding the "We Were Liars" Universe: Sequel vs. Prequel

When We Were Liars debuted in 2014, it captivated readers with its haunting prose, atmospheric island setting, and unforgettable climax. Years after its initial publication, a resurgence of popularity—driven in large part by online book communities like BookTok—introduced the novel to a new generation of readers. This renewed global interest prompted widespread questions regarding whether the story of the Sinclair family continues in a second book.

The short answer is that the series expanded, but not through a traditional sequel. E. Lockhart chose to write a prequel titled Family of Liars (published on May 3, 2022, by Delacorte Press).

To understand why the author opted for a prequel instead of a direct follow-up, it helps to examine how the original story concludes. We Were Liars centers on Cadence Sinclair Easton and her summer experiences on her family’s private island, Beechwood, located off the coast of Massachusetts. Because of the definitive nature of the climax in We Were Liars, a direct sequel continuing Cadence's journey would have altered the emotional resolution of her story arc. Instead, Lockhart turned her attention backward to explore the origin of the toxic family dynamics, secrecy, and high expectations that defined the adult Sinclairs in the original book.

"Family of Liars": Overview, Plot, and Setting

Family of Liars transports readers back to the summer of 1987 on Beechwood Island. The prequel shifts the narrative voice from Cadence to her aunt, Caroline "Carrie" Sinclair—the mother of Johnny and older sister to Penny (Cadence’s mother) and Bess (Mirren’s mother).

Sinclair Family Timeline:

  • 1987: Family of Liars
    • Narrator: Carrie Sinclair
    • Focus: Carrie, Penny, Bess, & Rosemary
    • Theme: Origins of family secrecy & trauma
  • Present: We Were Liars
    • Narrator: Cadence Sinclair Easton
    • Focus: The "Liars" (Cadence, Johnny, Mirren, Gat)
    • Theme: Uncovering repressed memories & consequences

The Plot Focus

In 1987, the Sinclair family is still recovering from a devastating tragedy: the drowning death of ten-year-old Rosemary Sinclair, the youngest of the four sisters. The narrative follows seventeen-year-old Carrie, who is struggling with profound grief, an addiction to prescription painkillers following jaw surgery, and the pressure to maintain the flawless exterior demanded by her parents, Harris and Tipper Sinclair.

During this pivotal summer, an unexpected group of visitors arrives on Beechwood Island, leading to romance, betrayal, drug use, and an unthinkable catastrophe. Carrie makes choices to protect her family that echo across decades, setting the stage for the dysfunctional dynamics seen in We Were Liars.

Key Themes in the Prequel

  • The Burden of Perfection: Like its predecessor, Family of Liars critiques the illusion of aristocratic perfection. The patriarch, Harris Sinclair, demands that his daughters display strength and composure at all times, refusing to allow public mourning or vulnerability.
  • Substance Abuse and Dependency: Carrie’s internal struggle with opioids provides a raw look at coping mechanisms within privileged environments where emotional pain is ignored.
  • Sisterhood and Complicity: The bond between Carrie, Penny, and Bess is tested as they become co-conspirators in keeping dangerous secrets to preserve their social status.
We Were Liars - A Must-Read Thriller | Good thriller books, Suspense ...
We Were Liars - A Must-Read Thriller | Good thriller books, Suspense ...

Comprehensive Comparison: "We Were Liars" vs. "Family of Liars"

To help readers understand how the two books fit together, the following table details the key differences between the original novel and its companion prequel.

Feature We Were Liars (Book 1 Published) Family of Liars (Book 2 Published)
Publication Date May 13, 2014 May 3, 2022
Chronological Placement Present day / Late 2000s Summer 1987 (27 years prior)
Book Type Original Standalone / Core Novel Companion Prequel
Primary Narrator Cadence Sinclair Easton Caroline "Carrie" Sinclair
Central Group The Liars (Cadence, Johnny, Mirren, Gat) The Sinclair Sisters (Carrie, Penny, Bess) & Visitors
Primary Setting Beechwood Island, Massachusetts Beechwood Island, Massachusetts
Main Conflict Cadence recovering lost memories of Summer 15 Carrie coping with grief, addiction, and a cover-up
Tone Poetic, haunting, mysterious Nostalgic, dark, dramatic
Page Count ~240 pages ~300 pages

Recommended Reading Order: Which Book Should You Read First?

Although Family of Liars takes place chronologically before We Were Liars, reading them in publication order is strongly recommended by both literary critics and narrative designers.

RECOMMENDED READING PATH:

  1. Read "We Were Liars" (First)
    • Experience the mystery, twist, and character fates firsthand.
  2. Read "Family of Liars" (Second)
    • Understand the ancestral trauma, parental motives, and historical context.

Why Read We Were Liars First?

  1. Preservation of Suspense: We Were Liars relies heavily on tension, reliable memory fragments, and a major plot revelation at its climax. Reading Family of Liars first reveals key character traits, generational patterns, and structural secrets about Beechwood Island that can lessen the psychological impact of the original book's ending.
  2. Understanding Parental Motives: In We Were Liars, the adult mothers (Carrie, Penny, and Bess) often appear petty, competitive, and obsessed with their inheritance. Reading We Were Liars first gives you a baseline perception of these parents; reading Family of Liars afterward recontextualizes their behavior, showing how their youth and past trauma shaped their adult flaws.
  3. Appreciating Authorial Intent: E. Lockhart wrote Family of Liars with the assumption that readers were already familiar with the atmosphere of Beechwood Island and the tragic legacy of the Sinclairs.

Special Editions and Bonus Content

Beyond the two main novels, readers interested in deep-diving into the Sinclair universe have access to expanded physical editions and supplementary materials.

We Were Liars Deluxe Edition

In 2018, Delacorte Press released a special Deluxe Edition of We Were Liars. This edition is valuable for dedicated readers because it includes:

  • The Original Hand-Drawn Map: Detailed layouts of Beechwood Island, including Clairmont, Windemere, Cuddledown, and Red Gate houses.
  • The Sinclair Family Tree: A visual reference mapping out generations of the family.
  • Author’s Notes and Deleted Scenes: Behind-the-scenes commentary from E. Lockhart detailing how the plot was crafted and alternative scenes that did not make the final cut.
  • The "Liars" Reading Group Guide: Discussion questions suitable for book clubs and classroom settings.

Adaptations and Expanding Media

The success of the Liars universe has extended beyond publishing into screen adaptations.

Amazon Prime Video ordered a television series adaptation of We Were Liars. The project was developed by prominent showrunners Julie Plec (The Vampire Diaries) and Carina Adly MacKenzie (Roswell, New Mexico).

The adaptation aims to bring the sun-drenched, high-suspense atmosphere of Beechwood Island to television, introducing the main quartet—Cadence, Johnny, Mirren, and Gat—to a broader audience. The existence of both We Were Liars and Family of Liars provides producers with deep lore and backstories to draw upon for potential multi-season storytelling.

Similar Books for Fans of E. Lockhart

If you have completed both We Were Liars and Family of Liars and are searching for books with similar themes—such as unreliable narrators, family secrets, wealthy dynasties, and dark thrillers—consider the following recommended titles:

  • "Genuine Fraud" by E. Lockhart: A psychological thriller about identity theft, murder, and complex female friendship, told in reverse chronological order.
  • "The Cousins" by Karen M. McManus: A story focusing on three cousins invited to their estranged grandmother's exclusive island resort, where dark family secrets come to light.
  • "The Inheritance Games" by Jennifer Lynn Barnes: A suspenseful novel centered on an unexpected fortune, complex puzzles, and a family willing to do anything to secure their wealth.
  • "Sadie" by Courtney Summers: A gripping, dark mystery presented partly through a true-crime podcast format, exploring themes of family devotion and revenge.
  • "One of Us Is Lying" by Karen M. McManus: A high-stakes mystery featuring high school students, secret-keeping, and unexpected plot twists.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is "Family of Liars" a direct sequel to "We Were Liars"?

No, Family of Liars is not a direct sequel. It is a prequel set 27 years before We Were Liars. It focuses on the teenage years of Cadence's aunt, Carrie Sinclair, during the summer of 1987, rather than continuing Cadence's story after the events of the first book.

Can you read "Family of Liars" as a standalone novel?

Yes, Family of Liars contains a self-contained plot that can be understood on its own. However, reading We Were Liars first provides essential context regarding the family dynamic and allows readers to fully appreciate the dramatic irony and character connections embedded in the narrative.

Will there be a third book in the "We Were Liars" series?

As of 2026, author E. Lockhart has not officially announced a third novel in the Liars universe. While she has expressed affection for the Sinclair family and Beechwood Island in past interviews, the series currently consists of the primary novel (We Were Liars) and its single prequel (Family of Liars).

Does Cadence Sinclair appear in "Family of Liars"?

No, Cadence Sinclair does not appear in Family of Liars. Because the prequel takes place in 1987, Cadence and her cousins (Johnny, Mirren, and Gat) have not yet been born. The book instead focuses on Cadence’s mother, Penny, her aunts, Carrie and Bess, and their late sister, Rosemary.

What order were the "We Were Liars" books published in?

We Were Liars was published first in May 2014. The prequel, Family of Liars, was published eight years later in May 2022.

Next Actions for Readers

If you want to continue exploring the world of Beechwood Island, follow these steps:

  1. If you have only read We Were Liars: Pick up a copy of Family of Liars to learn the backstories of Carrie, Penny, and Bess, and discover the historical events that shaped the Sinclair estate.
  2. If you haven't read either book: Begin with We Were Liars to experience the story's famous twist without prior spoilers, then proceed to Family of Liars.
  3. For collector features: Look for the Deluxe Edition of We Were Liars to examine official family tree diagrams and author notes regarding the construction of the mystery.