In Wisconsin, commissions are legally considered a part of an employee's "earnings" and must be included when calculating workers' compensation benefits. Under Wisconsin Statute Chapter 102, the "average weekly wage" used to determine disability payments incorporates all forms of monetary compensation, including base salary, commissions, bonuses, and even the value of certain fringe benefits.
Calculating workers' compensation benefits in Wisconsin involves more than simply looking at an employee's hourly rate. For professionals in sales, real estate, or automotive industries, commissions often represent the largest portion of their take-home pay. If you are injured on the job in 2026, ensuring these earnings are accurately reported is the difference between receiving a fair benefit and struggling with a significant financial shortfall.
The Legal Framework: Wisconsin Statute Section 102.11
The foundation for how commissions are handled lies in Wisconsin Statute § 102.11, which dictates the methods for determining the "average weekly wage" (AWW). The AWW is the most critical number in a workers' compensation claim because it serves as the basis for indemnity benefits, such as Temporary Total Disability (TTD) and Permanent Partial Disability (PPD).
The Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development (DWD) oversees these regulations to ensure that injured workers are compensated based on their actual earning capacity, rather than an arbitrary or minimized figure. The law explicitly recognizes that "earnings" include the cash value of all items received by the employee as part of the contract of hire. Because commissions are a direct result of the labor performed under that contract, they are inseparable from the base wage in the eyes of the law.
Why Commissions Matter for Indemnity Benefits
Indemnity benefits are designed to replace a portion of the wages lost due to a work-related injury. In Wisconsin, the standard rate for temporary disability is two-thirds (66.67%) of the employee's average weekly wage.
If an employee earns a base salary of $500 per week but averages an additional $1,000 per week in commissions, their true earning capacity is $1,500. If the insurance carrier only calculates the benefit based on the $500 base, the worker would receive roughly $333 per week. However, when commissions are correctly included, the benefit rises to the state maximum allowed for that year. Excluding commissions essentially penalizes the worker for having a performance-based pay structure.
How the Average Weekly Wage is Calculated with Commissions
The process of incorporating commissions into a workers' compensation claim is more complex than calculating benefits for a standard hourly worker. Wisconsin uses specific "look-back" periods to determine a fair average, especially for employees whose income fluctuates.
The 52-Week Look-Back Period
Under the current 2026 guidelines, the insurance carrier typically examines the 52 weeks of earnings immediately preceding the date of the injury. To find the average weekly wage for a commission-based employee:
- Sum all gross earnings (base pay + commissions + bonuses) earned in the 52 weeks prior to the injury.
- Divide that total by the number of weeks actually worked during that period.
- Compare this average to the "expansion" rules (often referred to as the "full-time" or "normal work week" rules) to ensure the worker isn't being undercompensated due to a recent slow period.
Handling Recent Hires
If an employee has not worked for the employer for a full year, the DWD provides alternative methods. The calculation may be based on the earnings of a similarly situated employee in the same role who has worked there for a year. If no such employee exists, the calculation reverts to the "contract of hire," which estimates what the employee was expected to earn, including projected commissions based on the business's standard performance metrics.
Common Components of "Earnings" in Wisconsin
Beyond standard commissions, other forms of performance-based pay are also included in the calculation. The following table outlines what is generally included versus excluded when determining the average weekly wage in Wisconsin.
| Included in Earnings | Excluded from Earnings |
|---|---|
| Gross Base Salary or Hourly Wages | Employer-paid Health Insurance Premiums |
| Sales Commissions | Employer Contributions to 401(k) |
| Performance Bonuses | Reimbursed Business Expenses (e.g., mileage) |
| Tips (if documented for tax purposes) | Per Diem for travel (unless it exceeds actual cost) |
| Value of Room and Board (if provided) | Discretionary Gifts (non-contractual) |
| Overtime Pay | Severance Pay |
The Impact of Commission Fluctuations and Seasonality
One of the most significant challenges for commission-based workers in Wisconsin is seasonality. For example, a car salesperson might earn 70% of their annual commissions during the spring and summer. If that worker is injured in January, a simple short-term average might reflect a much lower income than their actual annual capacity.
Wisconsin law attempts to mitigate this by favoring the 52-week average. By looking at a full year, the peaks and valleys of commission cycles are smoothed out. However, if an injury occurs during a period where the worker was significantly "under-employed" or if the commissions were abnormally low due to external factors (like a supply chain shortage or business downturn), there are legal avenues to argue for a more representative "contract of hire" wage.
The "Full-Time" Presumption
Wisconsin workers' compensation law contains a presumption that workers should be compensated based on a full-time work week (usually 40 hours), even if they were working fewer hours at the time of injury, unless they were part of a "restricted" labor market. For commission workers, this means that if their total earnings (base + commission) divided by their hours worked results in an hourly rate, that rate must be applied to at least a 40-hour week for the AWW calculation, provided they were generally available for full-time work.
Independent Contractors vs. Employees: A Critical Distinction
A major hurdle in commission-heavy industries—such as real estate, insurance sales, and logistics—is the classification of the worker. Only employees are eligible for workers' compensation. Independent contractors are generally not covered.
In Wisconsin, the DWD uses a strict nine-point test to determine if a worker is a true independent contractor. Just because a worker receives a 1099 instead of a W-2 and earns 100% commission does not automatically make them an independent contractor under workers' comp law. If the employer controls the details of the work, provides the equipment, or restricts the worker from working for others, the DWD may deem that individual an employee, making their commissions eligible for inclusion in a compensation claim.
Potential Disputes and "Wage Shaving"
"Wage shaving" occurs when an insurance company or employer intentionally or accidentally omits commissions, bonuses, or overtime from the AWW calculation. This is one of the most common sources of litigation in Wisconsin workers' compensation cases.
Common Tactics to Watch For:
- The "Base Only" Error: The insurer simply uses the base salary listed on the initial hire letter, ignoring years of commission growth.
- Excluding "Discretionary" Bonuses: Insurers may claim a bonus was a "gift" and not part of the wage contract. In Wisconsin, if the bonus is tied to performance or sales targets, it is almost always considered part of the wage.
- Improper Look-back Periods: The insurer might only look at the last four weeks of pay (which may have been low) rather than the required 52-week average.
If you suspect your commissions are being excluded, you have the right to request a wage statement (Form WKC-13-E1) from the insurance carrier. This form should detail every payment made to you in the year prior to the injury. Comparing this to your own pay stubs is the first step in identifying discrepancies.
Steps to Take if Commissions are Excluded
If you are a commission-based worker and have been injured, follow these steps to ensure your benefits are calculated accurately:
- Gather 52 Weeks of Pay Stubs: Do not rely on your employer’s records alone. Collect every pay stub or commission statement from the 12 months preceding your injury.
- Report "Gross" Income: Ensure the figures used for your claim are your gross earnings before taxes and deductions, not your "net" take-home pay.
- Audit the AWW: Ask the insurance adjuster for the specific calculation they used to arrive at your weekly benefit amount.
- File a Hearing Application: If the insurance company refuses to include commissions, you can file a formal "Application for Hearing" with the Wisconsin DWD. An Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) will then review the wage evidence.
- Consult a Specialist: Because commission calculations involve complex statutory interpretations, consulting with a workers' compensation attorney who understands the nuances of Section 102.11 is often necessary.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if I just started my job and haven't earned many commissions yet?
In Wisconsin, if you haven't worked long enough to establish a commission history, the law looks at the "contract of hire." This involves looking at what you were expected to earn or what a similar employee in your position earns. The insurance company cannot simply set your wage at $0 in commissions just because you haven't closed your first sale yet.
Are year-end bonuses included the same way as monthly commissions?
Yes. Any bonus that is part of your compensation package—meaning it is earned based on your labor or sales volume—is included. To calculate the weekly impact, the total annual bonus is typically divided by 52 and added to your average weekly wage.
If my commissions vary wildly month-to-month, which month do they use?
They do not use a single month. Wisconsin law requires an average, typically over the 52 weeks prior to the injury. This ensures that a single "bad month" doesn't unfairly lower your benefits, just as a single "peak month" doesn't artificially inflate them.
Does the state maximum cap apply to commission-based workers?
Yes. Wisconsin sets a maximum weekly compensation rate every year. Even if your commissions are so high that your 66.67% benefit would be $3,000 a week, you will be capped at the state’s maximum limit for that specific year. However, including your commissions is still vital to reaching that maximum cap.
Can an employer stop paying commissions while I am on workers' comp?
This is a complex area of employment law. While workers' compensation covers your "lost" earnings, it does not necessarily force an employer to pay you commissions on sales you did not make while you were out. However, if you are owed commissions for work completed before the injury, the employer must pay those regardless of your workers' compensation status.
Practical Recommendation for Wisconsin Workers
If your income is heavily dependent on commissions, you must be proactive from the first day of your injury. Do not assume the insurance company will automatically find every dollar you earned.
The most effective action you can take is to create a spreadsheet of your gross earnings (base plus all commissions/bonuses) for the 52 weeks prior to your injury. Compare the average of these 52 weeks to the "benefit rate" stated on your first workers' compensation check. If the check is less than two-thirds of your calculated average (up to the state maximum), immediately notify the insurance adjuster in writing and provide your documentation. In Wisconsin's 2026 legal landscape, documentation is the only definitive way to resolve wage disputes without lengthy litigation.