Skip to content
Lifestyle & Learning

Ariel Roman Case in Chicago Explained: A Comprehensive Timeline and Legal Analysis

In this article

The Ariel Roman case stems from a February 28, 2020, incident where Chicago Police officers shot an unarmed man at the Grand Red Line station following a struggle over a minor transit violation. The case became a focal point for debates regarding police use of force, the criminalization of low-level offenses, and the effectiveness of oversight in the Chicago Police Department (CPD).

The Incident at Grand Red Line Station: A Step-by-Step Breakdown

On the afternoon of February 28, 2020, Ariel Roman, a 33-year-old Chicago resident, was riding the CTA Red Line. The encounter began when two Chicago Police officers, Melvina Bogard and Bernard Butler, observed Roman moving between two cars of a moving train. Under Chicago’s municipal code, moving between train cars is a minor ordinance violation, typically resulting in a citation or a verbal warning.

The officers confronted Roman as the train arrived at the Grand station in the Near North Side neighborhood. When the officers attempted to detain him, Roman, who later stated he was experiencing anxiety, resisted their efforts to place him in handcuffs. The struggle moved from the train car onto the station platform.

The physical altercation lasted several minutes and was captured by multiple surveillance cameras and, most significantly, by a bystander’s cell phone video. The footage showed the officers struggling to subdue Roman on the ground. During the struggle, Officer Butler can be heard shouting, "Shoot him!" to his partner. Officer Bogard then deployed her Taser, which appeared to have little effect on Roman. As Roman broke free and stood up, moving toward the base of an escalator to flee, Officer Bogard drew her service weapon and fired twice.

Roman was struck once in the hip/buttocks area and once in the abdomen, with the second shot occurring as he was moving up the escalator away from the officers. He was critically injured but survived the shooting after undergoing multiple surgeries. He was initially charged with resisting arrest and aggravated battery to a peace officer, but those charges were dropped by the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office shortly after the video of the shooting went viral.

Analyzing Use of Force and CPD Policy

The central controversy of the Ariel Roman case lies in the escalation from a non-violent ordinance violation to the use of lethal force. According to the Chicago Police Department’s General Orders on the Use of Force, officers are prohibited from using lethal force against a person who is a threat only to themselves or who is merely fleeing without posing an imminent threat of death or great bodily harm to others.

The Proportionality of the Response

Critics and legal experts argued that the officers’ response was disproportionate to the "crime" committed. Moving between train cars is a violation often ignored or handled with a simple "get back inside." By escalating the situation into a physical struggle on a crowded station platform, the officers created a high-risk environment.

The "Shoot Him" Instruction

One of the most disturbing elements for the public was the verbal instruction from Officer Butler. In police training, lethal force is a last resort based on an individual officer's assessment of a threat. One officer telling another to fire their weapon—especially when the suspect is unarmed and attempting to flee—runs contrary to standard de-escalation protocols.

Taser Failure and Escalation

The failure of the Taser to incapacitate Roman led the officers to jump immediately to their firearms. Police reform advocates point to this as a failure in training, noting that "Taser failure" should lead to further de-escalation or physical control techniques rather than the immediate introduction of a firearm in a non-life-threatening scenario.

Chicago Sky's New Powerhouse: How Ariel Atkins could turn the tide in ...
Chicago Sky's New Powerhouse: How Ariel Atkins could turn the tide in ...

The Criminal Trial of Officer Melvina Bogard

Following an investigation by the Civilian Office of Police Accountability (COPA) and the Cook County State’s Attorney, Melvina Bogard was charged with aggravated battery and official misconduct. This was a rare instance of a Chicago police officer facing criminal charges for an on-duty shooting.

The case proceeded to a bench trial before Cook County Judge Leynee Flores in 2022. During the trial, prosecutors argued that Roman was "running for his life" and posed no threat when Bogard fired. They emphasized that Roman was unarmed and his back was partially turned.

Bogard’s defense argued that the officer was in fear for her safety and the safety of her partner. They claimed that Roman’s resistance was aggressive and that the chaotic environment of the subway station contributed to a perceived need for force.

In a decision that sparked significant protest, Judge Flores acquitted Bogard of all charges. The judge stated that the prosecution had failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Bogard’s actions were not a result of her fearing for her safety during a "tense, uncertain, and rapidly evolving" situation. While the acquittal meant Bogard would not face prison time, it did not end the administrative or civil repercussions of the incident.

The $2.25 Million Civil Settlement

While the criminal justice system found Bogard not guilty of a crime, the City of Chicago took a different path regarding civil liability. In 2022, the Chicago City Council’s Finance Committee recommended, and the full council approved, a $2.25 million settlement for Ariel Roman.

Settlements of this nature are not admissions of guilt by the city but are "risk management" decisions. Given the clear video evidence of Roman being shot while fleeing up an escalator, city attorneys likely determined that a jury would have awarded a significantly higher amount if the case had gone to a civil trial.

The settlement was intended to cover Roman’s extensive medical bills, long-term physical therapy, and the psychological trauma resulting from the shooting. Roman suffered permanent injuries, including the loss of a portion of his organs due to the path of the bullets.

Administrative Consequences and COPA Findings

The Civilian Office of Police Accountability (COPA) conducted an exhaustive review of the shooting. Their findings were much harsher than the criminal court’s verdict. COPA recommended that both Melvina Bogard and Bernard Butler be fired from the Chicago Police Department.

  1. Melvina Bogard: COPA found her use of force was unnecessary and violated several department policies. The Chicago Police Board eventually voted to terminate her employment, concluding that her decision to fire her weapon into a fleeing suspect was a gross violation of the department's sanctity of life policy.
  2. Bernard Butler: Although he did not pull the trigger, COPA and the Police Board found that Butler failed to de-escalate the situation and actively encouraged the use of lethal force. Butler was also separated from the department.

As of 2026, neither officer remains on the force. Their names were added to the "do not hire" list for many municipal law enforcement agencies, although the impact of their decertification continues to be a topic of discussion in Illinois police reform circles.

Comparative Overview of Case Outcomes

Category Details/Outcome
Initial Violation Moving between CTA train cars (Ordinance Violation)
Criminal Charges (Roman) Resisting Arrest, Aggravated Battery (All Charges Dropped)
Criminal Charges (Bogard) Aggravated Battery, Official Misconduct (Acquitted)
Civil Settlement $2.25 Million paid by the City of Chicago to Ariel Roman
Employment Status Both officers terminated by the Chicago Police Board
Medical Impact Roman suffered two gunshot wounds; permanent internal damage

Long-term Impact on Chicago Transit Policing

The Ariel Roman case catalyzed several changes in how the CTA is policed and how the city handles "quality of life" crimes.

Shift in Enforcement Priorities

Following the backlash, the CPD Transit Command received new directives emphasizing that minor ordinance violations (like smoking on the platform or moving between cars) should not be the primary reason for high-stakes physical confrontations unless a direct public safety threat exists.

Body-Worn Cameras on the CTA

While surveillance cameras were present at the Grand station, the Roman case highlighted the need for more comprehensive Body-Worn Camera (BWC) footage. The department accelerated the rollout of BWCs to all officers assigned to the transit detail to ensure multiple angles of any future incidents are available for review.

De-escalation Training

The case is now used as a training example for what not to do in a transit environment. Training modules specifically highlight the Roman incident to teach officers about "perceived vs. actual threat" and the dangers of discharging a firearm in a confined space like a subway station.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was Ariel Roman armed during the encounter?

No. Investigations by both the Chicago Police Department and the Civilian Office of Police Accountability confirmed that Ariel Roman was unarmed throughout the entire interaction.

Why was Officer Bogard acquitted if the shooting was on video?

In criminal law, the burden of proof is "beyond a reasonable doubt." The judge in the bench trial ruled that the prosecution did not sufficiently disprove the defense's claim that the officer acted out of a perceived fear for her safety during a chaotic struggle. The legal standard for "reasonable fear" in police trials often provides a high threshold for conviction.

What happened to the other officer, Bernard Butler?

While Officer Butler did not fire the shots, he was fired from the Chicago Police Department. The Police Board determined that his failure to manage the scene and his verbal command for his partner to "shoot" were violations of department policy and ethical standards.

Has the CTA changed its rules about moving between cars?

The rule (Municipal Code 10-8-525) still exists for safety reasons—moving between cars is dangerous. However, the enforcement of the rule has changed. Officers are now encouraged to use verbal warnings or simple citations rather than physical detention for this specific violation.

What is Ariel Roman's current status?

As of 2026, Ariel Roman has largely moved out of the public eye following his settlement. He continues to deal with the long-term physical effects of his injuries. His case remains a staple of legal discussions regarding civil rights and police accountability in Illinois.

Practical Recommendations and Next Actions

For those following the Ariel Roman case or similar incidents of police misconduct in Chicago, staying informed through official channels is essential.

  1. Monitor COPA Reports: The Civilian Office of Police Accountability publishes detailed reports on all officer-involved shootings. These provide technical details often omitted in news summaries.
  2. Understand "Use of Force" Guidelines: Review the Chicago Police Department’s General Orders to understand the specific rules officers are required to follow regarding de-escalation and firearms.
  3. Legal Resources: If you or someone you know is involved in a transit-related police encounter, remember that you have the right to remain silent and the right to an attorney. Video recording police in public spaces in Illinois is legal, provided it does not physically interfere with their duties.
  4. Follow the Chicago Police Board: The Board holds monthly public meetings where disciplinary actions against officers are discussed and decided. This is a critical venue for public oversight.