The voice cast for Batman: Arkham Knight features a blend of industry legends and high-profile screen actors, led by Kevin Conroy as Batman and Mark Hamill as the Joker. The titular antagonist, the Arkham Knight, was voiced by Troy Baker, who also portrayed Two-Face. Other major cast members include John Noble as Scarecrow, Jonathan Banks as James Gordon, and Ashley Greene as Barbara Gordon (Oracle).
The Evolution of the Arkhamverse Cast
By 2026, the legacy of the Arkham series remains a gold standard for superhero storytelling in gaming. When Rocksteady Studios first revealed the cast for the trilogy's conclusion, it signaled a shift toward a more cinematic, somber tone. While Arkham Asylum and Arkham City leaned heavily on the iconic 1990s Batman: The Animated Series roster, Arkham Knight introduced several key casting changes and high-profile additions to elevate the stakes of Batman’s "final" night in Gotham.
The casting strategy for Arkham Knight was twofold: preserve the emotional core of the series by retaining the legendary dynamic between Conroy and Hamill, while refreshing the supporting cast with actors known for "gritty" television dramas. This approach helped differentiate the game from its predecessors, moving away from the "comic book" feel and into the realm of a dark, psychological thriller.
The Pillars: Conroy, Hamill, and the Internal Conflict
The heart of the Arkham Knight reveal was the confirmation that Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill would return. In 2026, looking back after the passing of Kevin Conroy, his performance in this title is often cited as his most nuanced.
Kevin Conroy as Batman / Bruce Wayne
Conroy’s portrayal in Arkham Knight is significantly more weary and strained than in previous entries. The casting reveal emphasized a Batman at his breaking point. Throughout the game, Conroy delivers a performance that balances the character’s physical dominance with his mental fragility as he battles the Joker’s "blood infection."
Mark Hamill as The Joker
While the Joker died at the end of Arkham City, Hamill’s return was the most significant "secret" reveal of the production. Acting as a hallucination or a "ghost" within Bruce Wayne’s mind, Hamill’s performance is arguably more frequent and interactive than in any previous game. He serves as a dark narrator, mocking Batman’s failures and highlighting the cast’s shifting dynamics.
The New Threats: Scarecrow and the Arkham Knight
The primary antagonists required voices that could command fear and mystery. Rocksteady shifted away from the more manic versions of these characters seen in earlier iterations.
John Noble as Scarecrow
One of the most praised casting choices was John Noble, known for his roles in Fringe and The Lord of the Rings. Noble replaced Dino Andrade, who voiced Scarecrow in Arkham Asylum. The decision to cast Noble brought a cold, calculating, and intellectual menace to the character. His deep, resonant voice turned Scarecrow from a gimmicky villain into a credible global threat capable of uniting Gotham’s underworld.
Troy Baker as The Arkham Knight
The identity of the Arkham Knight was the central mystery of the 2015 release. When the cast was revealed, Troy Baker was already a household name in gaming (The Last of Us, Bioshock Infinite). However, his role as the Knight was initially kept under wraps to protect the plot twist. Baker utilized a digitally altered, aggressive tone for the Knight, contrasting sharply with his smoother, more traditional performance as Two-Face in the same game.
The eventual reveal that the Arkham Knight was Jason Todd (the former Robin) allowed Baker to transition into a performance filled with vengeful rage and tragic vulnerability. This dual-casting of Baker showcased his range and cemented him as a staple of the franchise.
The Bat-Family and Allies: A Changing of the Guard
Several major supporting roles were recast for Arkham Knight, a move that initially sparked debate among fans but ultimately served the game’s more realistic aesthetic.
Jonathan Banks as Commissioner James Gordon
Taking over for Tom Kane (Asylum) and Rick D. Wasserman (City), Jonathan Banks (Breaking Bad, Better Call Saul) brought a weathered, paternal authority to Jim Gordon. Banks’ performance grounded the character, making Gordon feel like a man who had truly spent decades fighting a losing battle against Gotham’s corruption.
Ashley Greene as Barbara Gordon (Oracle)
Ashley Greene (Twilight) replaced Kimberly Brooks as the voice of Oracle. This change was part of the push for a more "Hollywood" cast. Greene’s Barbara Gordon is central to the emotional stakes of the game, particularly during the sequences involving her abduction by the Arkham Knight.
The Proteges: Nightwing and Robin
- Scott Porter as Nightwing (Dick Grayson): Porter provided a confident, slightly quippy energy that served as a necessary foil to Batman’s brooding.
- Matthew Mercer as Robin (Tim Drake): Mercer, now iconic for his work in Critical Role, delivered a more mature and capable Tim Drake than previously seen, highlighting the character's growth into a hero who could potentially succeed Batman.
The Rogues' Gallery: Consistency and Chaos
While the lead roles saw significant changes, much of the villainous supporting cast remained consistent, ensuring a sense of continuity within the Arkhamverse.
- Tara Strong as Harley Quinn: Following her debut as the character in Arkham City, Strong continued to evolve Harley into a more grieving, vengeful figure following the Joker’s death.
- Nolan North as The Penguin: North used a rough, Cockney-inspired accent that completely transformed his natural voice, making Oswald Cobblepot a brutal mob boss rather than a cartoonish aristocrat.
- Wally Wingert as The Riddler: Wingert’s performance remained a highlight, capturing the character’s obsessive-compulsive need for intellectual validation through thousands of lines of recorded dialogue.
- Tasia Valenza as Poison Ivy: Valenza returned to voice Ivy, whose role in Arkham Knight shifted from a pure villain to a reluctant anti-hero, providing one of the game's most pivotal narrative moments.
Complete Voice Cast and Character Reference Table
The following table outlines the primary cast revealed for the main campaign of Batman: Arkham Knight.
| Character | Voice Actor | Notable Previous Work | Role Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Batman / Bruce Wayne | Kevin Conroy | Batman: The Animated Series | Protagonist |
| The Joker | Mark Hamill | Star Wars, Avatar: TLA | Main Antagonist (Psychological) |
| Scarecrow | John Noble | Fringe, Sleepy Hollow | Main Antagonist (Physical/Plot) |
| The Arkham Knight | Troy Baker | The Last of Us, Uncharted 4 | Main Antagonist (Identity Secret) |
| James Gordon | Jonathan Banks | Breaking Bad, Community | Primary Ally |
| Barbara Gordon / Oracle | Ashley Greene | Twilight Saga, Pan Am | Primary Ally / Intel |
| Alfred Pennyworth | Martin Jarvis | Titanic, Wreck-it Ralph | Support |
| Harley Quinn | Tara Strong | Teen Titans, Fairly OddParents | Supporting Villain |
| Nightwing | Scott Porter | Friday Night Lights, Hart of Dixie | Playable Ally (DLC/Dual Play) |
| Robin | Matthew Mercer | Critical Role, Overwatch | Playable Ally (Dual Play) |
| Catwoman | Grey DeLisle | Avatar: TLA, Scooby-Doo | Ally / Love Interest |
| The Penguin | Nolan North | Uncharted, Destiny 2 | Supporting Villain |
| Two-Face | Troy Baker | Fullmetal Alchemist | Supporting Villain |
| The Riddler | Wally Wingert | Invader Zim | Side Quest Antagonist |
| Poison Ivy | Tasia Valenza | Star Wars: The Clone Wars | Supporting Ally/Villain |
Why the Arkham Knight Reveal Was Controversial
When Rocksteady first marketed the game, they claimed the Arkham Knight was a "completely original character" created in collaboration with DC Comics. This led to intense speculation during the cast reveal phase. Fans scrutinized voice actor interviews and IMDB leaks to determine if the "original" character was simply a cover for an established figure from the comics.
The reveal of Troy Baker as the Knight was a double-edged sword. While Baker is an exceptional actor, his history of voicing Jason Todd/Red Hood in other media (and his role as Two-Face in the same game) led many to correctly guess the twist long before the game’s launch. Despite this, the performance remains a high point of the 2015 gaming year, as Baker captured the specific trauma of a student betrayed by his mentor.
Technical Execution of the Voice Performances
In Arkham Knight, Rocksteady utilized advanced facial motion capture technology. Unlike earlier games where voice acting and animation were often handled separately, the 2015 title saw actors like John Noble and Kevin Conroy providing more expressive performances that were mapped directly onto the character models.
This technical depth allowed for more subtle storytelling. For example, the micro-expressions on Commissioner Gordon's face during his confrontations with Batman carry a weight that voice acting alone could not achieve. The "Dual Play" system also required actors to record extensive banter, showing the chemistry between Batman and his allies during active combat sequences.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the voice of the Arkham Knight?
The Arkham Knight is voiced by Troy Baker. Baker also provides the voice for Two-Face (Harvey Dent) in the same game. When the character’s identity is revealed as Jason Todd, the vocal performance shifts from a synthesized, robotic tone to a raw, emotional delivery that reflects Jason's history as the second Robin.
Did the voice of Batman change in Arkham Knight?
No, Kevin Conroy returned to voice Batman in Arkham Knight. He has voiced the character in every Rocksteady-developed Arkham game. While Roger Craig Smith voiced a younger Batman in the prequel Arkham Origins, Conroy remains the definitive voice for the main trilogy.
Why did they change the voice of Jim Gordon?
The change to Jonathan Banks was a creative decision to align with the game’s more "prestige drama" tone. While previous actors Tom Kane and Rick D. Wasserman provided excellent comic-style performances, Banks brought a "noir" sensibility that matched the dark, rainy atmosphere of the final chapter.
Is Mark Hamill really in Arkham Knight?
Yes. Despite the Joker’s death in the previous game, Mark Hamill returns as a major character. He appears as a visual and auditory hallucination caused by the Fear Toxin and the "Joker infection" in Bruce Wayne's blood. He has more lines of dialogue in Arkham Knight than in many of his previous Batman appearances.
Who voices Catwoman in the game?
Grey DeLisle (also known as Grey Griffin) returns as Selina Kyle/Catwoman. She has voiced the character throughout the Arkham series, providing a performance that balances the character’s flirtatious nature with her formidable combat skills.
Practical Recommendation for Fans
If you are revisiting Batman: Arkham Knight in 2026, pay close attention to the audio logs and Gotham City Stories found in the evidence room and the Riddler menu. These files contain hours of additional voice work from the main cast that flesh out the events leading up to the game. Furthermore, for those interested in the craft of voice acting, the "Behind the Scenes" features (available in most Premium editions of the game) offer a rare look at Kevin Conroy and John Noble in the recording booth, providing context for how these iconic performances were constructed.