Skip to content
Insurance & Coverage

Are Scars Covered Under NYS Workers’ Compensation? Understanding Disfigurement Awards

In this article

Yes, New York State Workers’ Compensation provides specific benefits for permanent scars and disfigurement resulting from a work-related injury. Under the New York Workers' Compensation Law, injured workers may be eligible for a "schedule loss of use" or a "non-schedule" award specifically for serious facial, head, or neck disfigurement, provided the scarring is permanent and significant enough to be considered unsightly.

The Legal Basis for Disfigurement Claims in New York

In the New York Workers' Compensation system, the goal of benefits is generally to replace lost wages and cover medical expenses. However, the law recognizes that certain injuries carry consequences beyond physical impairment or functional limitations. Section 15, subdivision 3, paragraph t of the New York Workers’ Compensation Law specifically addresses "serious facial or head disfigurement."

When an employee suffers an injury that leaves a lasting visual mark, the Workers’ Compensation Board (WCB) evaluates that mark to determine if it meets the criteria for a monetary award. Unlike medical bills, which are paid based on services rendered, a disfigurement award is a lump-sum payment intended to compensate the worker for the aesthetic, social, and potential professional impact of having a permanent, visible scar.

To qualify, the scar must be the direct result of a work-related accident or occupational disease. It is not enough for the scar to exist; it must be documented in medical reports, and the WCB must conduct a formal evaluation to determine the severity and the corresponding value of the claim.

Eligibility Criteria: What Constitutes a Compensable Scar?

Not every minor scratch or surgical incision will result in a Workers’ Compensation award. The Board applies rigorous standards to determine what qualifies as "serious" disfigurement. While the law uses the term "serious facial or head disfigurement," administrative practices have expanded this to include the neck area as well.

Key Factors Considered by the Board

  1. Permanency: The scar must be fully healed and permanent. The Board typically will not evaluate a scar until a sufficient amount of time has passed—usually at least one year—to ensure that the appearance has stabilized.
  2. Visibility: The injury must be located in a region that is typically visible to others during normal social or professional interactions. This primarily covers the face, the forehead, the scalp, and the neck.
  3. Severity: The disfigurement must be considered "serious" or "unsightly." A thin, faint line that is barely noticeable under normal lighting conditions may not qualify. Deep lacerations, keloid scarring, irregular texture, or significant discoloration are more likely to be recognized as compensable.
  4. Causation: There must be a clear link between the workplace accident and the resulting scar. If a worker had a scar prior to the accident, the Board will only consider the portion of the disfigurement that was caused or exacerbated by the work-related incident.

The Evaluation Process: How the Board Determines Value

The process of receiving an award for a scar differs significantly from the process for a standard medical claim. Once a physician has determined that the scar has reached "Maximum Medical Improvement" (MMI), a hearing is typically scheduled before a Workers’ Compensation Law Judge (WCLJ).

During this hearing, the claimant must appear in person. The judge will examine the scar to assess its size, location, and overall appearance. Because the determination is somewhat subjective, the judge relies on their own observation, medical photographs, and the reports provided by the claimant’s physician.

Table: Comparison of Compensation Types for Scars

Feature Schedule Loss of Use (SLU) Disfigurement Award
Primary Basis Functional loss of a body part Aesthetic/Visual impact
Eligible Areas Extremities (arms, legs, eyes, etc.) Face, head, and neck
Determining Factor Percentage of loss of function Appearance and unsightliness
Nature of Payment Statutory week-based calculation Discretionary lump sum by judge

Limitations and Exclusions

It is essential to manage expectations regarding these claims. While the law provides for these awards, they are not intended to be "pain and suffering" damages in the way a personal injury lawsuit might provide. New York Workers' Compensation is a "no-fault" system, which limits the amount of compensation available for non-economic losses.

  • Body Location: Scars on the arms, torso, or legs are generally not eligible for a specific "disfigurement" award under the New York statute. These injuries are only compensated if they lead to a functional loss (Schedule Loss of Use) of that body part.
  • The "Double Recovery" Rule: If an injury results in both a functional loss (such as a stiff finger) and a cosmetic scar, the claimant generally cannot collect a separate disfigurement award if the disability award already covers the impairment in full, though practices can vary based on the specifics of the case and the presiding judge.
  • Cap on Awards: The Board has established guidelines for maximum awards based on the severity of the disfigurement. Because these are subject to the discretion of the judge, they are not guaranteed to be high in value.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can I get a disfigurement award for a scar on my arm? Generally, no. Under New York Workers’ Compensation law, disfigurement awards are specifically designated for the face, head, and neck. Scars on the arms or legs are only compensable if they cause a functional impairment that falls under the Schedule Loss of Use guidelines.

2. How much money will I receive for my facial scar? There is no fixed price list for scars. The amount is determined by a Workers’ Compensation Law Judge after a hearing. The judge considers the length, depth, color, and location of the scar, as well as its impact on the individual's appearance. It is a discretionary, one-time payment.

3. Do I need a lawyer for a disfigurement claim? While you are not required to have an attorney, navigating Workers’ Compensation hearings can be complex. An experienced attorney can help ensure that your medical records properly document the scar’s severity and that you are prepared for the hearing where the judge will make their assessment.

4. What if my scar is getting better? If a doctor believes the scar will continue to fade or improve significantly, the Board will likely postpone your hearing. You must reach "Maximum Medical Improvement" before the Board will calculate a final award, as the final appearance of the scar is the primary metric for the payment.

5. Does the employer's insurance company get a say in the amount? Yes. The insurance carrier is entitled to have their own medical expert examine the scar and provide an opinion on its severity. They may argue that the scar is minor or that it does not reach the legal threshold of being "serious," which can lead to a dispute that the judge must then resolve.

Preparing for Your Hearing

If you are planning to pursue a claim for disfigurement, documentation is your most important tool. Ensure your medical provider includes detailed descriptions of the scarring in their progress notes. High-quality, clear photographs taken from multiple angles under good lighting can also serve as powerful evidence, especially if the scar changes slightly over time.

Be prepared for the reality that the hearing process is visual and objective. You will be expected to stand before the judge so they can view the area clearly. It is also helpful to have a record of any psychological impact if the scarring has caused significant distress, although this is usually secondary to the visual assessment.

Seeking Professional Guidance

The complexities of the New York State Workers’ Compensation Board procedures mean that small errors in filing or failing to provide sufficient documentation can lead to a denial of your request for a disfigurement award. If you have sustained a significant injury that has left permanent scarring, consult with a licensed professional who understands the nuances of Section 15 of the Workers’ Compensation Law. They can assist in gathering the necessary medical evidence and representing your interests during the formal hearing process.