Skip to content
Entertainment & Biography

Ansel Elgort and Rachel Zegler in West Side Story: Casting, Chemistry, and Critical Legacy

In this article

In Steven Spielberg's 2021 film adaptation of West Side Story, Ansel Elgort and Rachel Zegler star as the central star-crossed lovers, Tony and María. Their performances combined live musical vocals with Tony Kushner’s updated, character-driven screenplay, bringing a fresh physical and emotional dynamic to Arthur Laurents, Leonard Bernstein, and Stephen Sondheim’s classic 1957 Broadway musical.

While the film received widespread critical acclaim for its visual grandeur, vocal realism, and vibrant choreography, the pairing of Elgort—an established Hollywood actor—and Zegler—a high school student making her feature film debut—became one of the most discussed casting choices of recent cinematic history. Exploring how Elgort and Zegler were cast, their musical dynamics on set, the critical evaluation of their onscreen chemistry, and how off-screen circumstances shaped the film’s release provides essential context for film history enthusiasts and musical theatre fans alike.

The Road to Casting: Finding Tony and María

Director Steven Spielberg and casting director Cindy Tolan spent over a year searching for the ideal actors to portray Tony and María. Unlike the 1961 film adaptation directed by Robert Wise and Jerome Robbins—which famously cast non-Hispanic actress Natalie Wood as María and dubbed the singing voices of both leads—Spielberg made two firm commitments from the outset: every actor playing a Puerto Rican character would be of Hispanic or Latine descent, and all actors would perform their own singing.

Casting Timeline Highlights:

  • January 2018: Open casting call announced for Latinx actors for María, Anita, Bernardo
  • October 2018: Ansel Elgort officially cast as Tony
  • January 2019: Rachel Zegler selected as María out of 30,000+ applicants

Rachel Zegler’s Discovery

Rachel Zegler’s path to the role of María reads like a classic Hollywood discovery story. In early 2018, as a 16-year-old high school student in Clifton, New Jersey, Zegler saw a tweet calling for submissions for Latinx actors for the roles of María, Anita, and Bernardo. Having previously played María in a local regional theater production, Zegler submitted a video of herself singing "Tonight" and "Me Siento Extraña" ("I Feel Pretty" in Spanish).

Selected from more than 30,000 applicants worldwide, Zegler underwent nearly a year of callbacks, chemistry reads, and vocal assessments before officially securing the role in January 2019 at age 17. Her technical vocal control, classical soprano range, and expressive vulnerability immediately convinced Spielberg and music director Jeanine Tesori that she possessed the vocal authority required for Bernstein's challenging score.

Ansel Elgort’s Selection

Ansel Elgort came to the project with an established Hollywood resume. Following breakout roles in young adult adaptations like The Fault in Our Stars (2014) and his critically praised turn in Edgar Wright’s action thriller Baby Driver (2017), Elgort was cast as Tony in October 2018.

Unlike many contemporary film actors, Elgort possessed formal performing arts training. He attended the Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School of Music & Art and Performing Arts in New York City and spent years studying ballet and vocal performance. Spielberg sought an actor who could project both physical intimidation as a former leader of the Jets street gang and believable earnestness as a young man trying to turn his life around. Elgort’s tall frame (6'4") and baritone-tenor singing voice fit the physical and vocal blueprint required for Kushner’s reimagined Tony.

Onscreen Chemistry and Musical Collaboration

The romantic believability of West Side Story hinges entirely on the instant, overwhelming connection between Tony and María. In Spielberg's version, Kushner’s script alters their meeting and courtship to heighten the emotional stakes and ground their attraction in shared isolation.

Key Duets & Shared Sequences:

  1. The Gym Dance ("Mambo"): Initial glance behind the bleachers
  2. "Tonight" (Balcony Scene): Fire escape declaration of love
  3. "One Hand, One Heart": Symbolic wedding at The Cloisters
  4. "A Boy Like That / I Have a Love": Climax of María's grief and devotion

The Fire Escape Sequence ("Tonight")

The iconic balcony scene—staged on a labyrinthine New York City fire escape—serves as the emotional centerpiece of Elgort and Zegler's shared performance. Choreographed by Justin Peck, the staging requires intricate physical coordination as Tony climbs scaffolding, ladders, and iron grates to reach María.

Musically, the sequence emphasized vocal authenticity. Under the direction of supervisor Jeanine Tesori and vocal coach Matt Sullivan, both actors performed their singing live on set during key takes, blending live recordings with studio sessions to ensure the vocals matched the kinetic energy of the scene. Zegler’s crystalline soprano provided a soaring counterpoint to Elgort’s softer, romantic vocal delivery, creating a musical contrast that highlighted María’s innocence and Tony’s longing for redemption.

Reimagining "One Hand, One Heart"

In the 1961 film, "One Hand, One Heart" takes place inside Madame Lucia's bridal shop, where Tony and María pretend to marry using mannequins. Spielberg and Kushner relocated the scene to The Cloisters—a branch of the Metropolitan Museum of Art dedicated to medieval art and architecture.

This venue change altered the dynamic between Elgort and Zegler. Surrounded by medieval stained glass and religious artifacts, their performance shifted from playfulness to solemn spiritual devotion. The physical height difference between Elgort and Zegler (nearly a foot apart) was staged to emphasize protection and vulnerability, with Zegler’s performance asserting emotional leadership even as Elgort’s character sought absolution for his violent past.

Performance Analysis: Nuances in Acting and Characterization

Tony Kushner’s screenplay substantially expanded the backstories of both lead characters, giving Elgort and Zegler different material to work with compared to their 1961 predecessors.

Rachel Zegler’s María: Agency and Cultural Grounding

Rather than depicting María as a passive romantic archetype, Zegler’s portrayal gives the character clear personal agency, stubbornness, and independence:

  • Economic Autonomy: María works night shifts at Gimbels department store alongside Anita (Ariana DeBose), establishing her desire for self-sufficiency in New York.
  • Cultural Authenticity: Zegler seamlessly transitions between English and conversational Spanish without artificial subtitles, fulfilling Spielberg’s direction to represent the Puerto Rican diaspora authentically.
  • Emotional Arc: Zegler navigates the rapid shift from youthful enthusiasm in "I Feel Pretty" to devastating grief in the film’s tragic climax, earning widespread critical praise for her dramatic restraint.

Ansel Elgort’s Tony: Trauma and Rejection of Violence

Elgort’s Tony is written with a darker, more concrete background than earlier iterations:

  • The Prison Backstory: Kushner reveals that Tony served a year at Sing Sing correctional facility for nearly beating a rival gang member to death. This backstory makes his refusal to fight the Sharks grounded in traumatic self-awareness rather than simple romance.
  • Physicality: Elgort plays Tony with a stooped, hesitant posture—a man trying to contain his size and violent potential—which contrasts sharply with his soaring vocal numbers like "Something's Coming."
  • Vulnerability: Critics noted that Elgort played Tony with an unvarnished, almost naive earnestness, emphasizing his desperation to build a life outside the Jets' territorial hatred.

Critical Reception and Comparison of Performance Dynamics

Upon the film's release in December 2021, critics analyzed the dynamic between the two leads within the broader ensemble cast. While the film as a whole garnered a 91% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes and seven Academy Award nominations, reviews of the lead performances highlighted a distinct contrast in critical consensus.

Critical Consensus Highlights:

  • Rachel Zegler: Universal praise for vocals, emotional range, and screen presence
  • Ansel Elgort: Mixed-to-positive reviews; praised for singing, critiqued for charisma
  • Ensemble Impact: Ariana DeBose (Anita) & Mike Faist (Riff) stole major critical focus

The Breakout Acclaim for Rachel Zegler

Film critics almost unanimously celebrated Zegler's debut. Writing for The New York Times, Manohla Dargis praised Zegler’s luminescent screen presence and vocal precision, noting that she carried the emotional weight of the film's final act with remarkable maturity. Film critic Richard Brody of The New Yorker highlighted her ability to ground Bernstein's operatic demands in realistic human emotion.

Zegler’s performance earned her several major accolades:

  • Golden Globe Award: Best Actress – Motion Picture Comedy or Musical (2022)
  • National Board of Review: Best Actress (2021)
  • Critics' Choice Movie Award Nomination: Best Young Performer (2022)

Evaluating Ansel Elgort’s Tony

Elgort’s performance received a more divided response. Many critics praised his singing ability, noting that his renditions of "Maria" and "Something's Coming" showed impressive technical control and genuine emotion. Critics from outlets like Variety and The Hollywood Reporter commended his physical commit to Kushner’s reworked, remorseful Tony.

However, other reviewers felt Elgort lacked the raw charismatic magnetism displayed by supporting actors Mike Faist (who played Jets leader Riff) and Ariana DeBose (who won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress as Anita). Critics frequently noted that the electrifying screen presence of Faist and DeBose occasionally overshadowed the central romantic pairing during group sequences.

Detailed Comparison: 1961 vs. 2021 Lead Pairings

To understand the stylistic and technical shifts in Elgort and Zegler's portrayal, it is helpful to compare their work with the original 1961 cinematic leads, Richard Beymer and Natalie Wood.

Feature / Metric 1961 Film (Beymer & Wood) 2021 Film (Elgort & Zegler)
Tony Actor Richard Beymer Ansel Elgort
María Actor Natalie Wood Rachel Zegler
Vocal Execution Dubbed by Jimmy Bryant & Marni Nixon Performed directly by Elgort & Zegler (Live + Studio)
María's Casting Background Non-Hispanic actress with dark makeup Latina actress of Colombian and Polish descent
Tony's Character Backstory Co-founder of Jets; left gang to work at Doc's Served 1 year at Sing Sing for assault; living at Doc's store
Key Duet Staging Studio set balcony; stylized romantic movement Real-location fire escapes & The Cloisters museum
Major Awards Recognition Beymer (Golden Globe nom); Wood (Unnominated for WSS) Zegler (Golden Globe Winner, NBR Winner)

Off-Screen Challenges and Promotional Press Dynamics

The publicity campaign and public reception of the 2021 release of West Side Story were significantly affected by external controversies surrounding Ansel Elgort, as well as production delays stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic.

Production & Release Timeline:

  • July 2019 – September 2019: Principal photography takes place in New York & New Jersey
  • June 2020: Social media allegations emerge involving Elgort; public response issued
  • December 2020: Original scheduled release date (postponed due to COVID-19)
  • December 2021: Official theatrical release by 20th Century Studios / Disney

Personal Allegations and Studio Strategy

In June 2020—roughly six months after filming concluded—an allegation of sexual misconduct from 2014 was raised against Ansel Elgort on social media. Elgort issued a statement denying allegations of illegal conduct or non-consensual assault, stating that he had engaged in a brief, consensual relationship with the individual when he was 20 years old.

As the film prepared for its delayed release in December 2021, 20th Century Studios and Disney managed the promotional press tour by shifting primary media focus onto director Steven Spielberg, screenwriter Tony Kushner, and supporting stars Rachel Zegler, Ariana DeBose, David Alvarez, and Rita Moreno (who returned as Valentina). Elgort participated in premiere screenings and cast group interviews but completed limited solo press appearances.

Professional Navigation by Rachel Zegler

For Rachel Zegler, the press tour represented her introduction to the global media landscape. At just 20 years old during the December 2021 press rollout, Zegler handled complex questions regarding her co-star, the cultural weight of the film's representation, and the pressure of starring in a major studio musical. Her poise throughout the press circuit was widely praised by industry observers, helping establish her reputation as a resilient and articulate public figure.

Subsequent Career Trajectories (Post-West Side Story)

The launchpad of West Side Story led to distinct career paths for both leads following the film's release.

Post-West Side Story Careers:

  • Rachel Zegler: Blockbuster franchises (Shazam!, Hunger Games) & Stage debut (Broadway's Romeo + Juliet)
  • Ansel Elgort: Television drama focus (Tokyo Vice lead role on Max)

Rachel Zegler’s Rapid Ascension

Zegler transitioned immediately from her debut into major Hollywood franchises and theatre roles:

  1. DC Extended Universe: Cast as Anthea in Shazam! Fury of the Gods (2023).
  2. The Hunger Games Franchise: Starred as Lucy Gray Baird in the prequel The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes (2023), performing her own live vocals on the folk-infused soundtrack.
  3. Disney Live-Action: Selected to play the title role in Disney's live-action reimagining of Snow White.
  4. Broadway Debut: Made her Broadway debut in late 2024 playing Juliet in a revival of Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet alongside Kit Connor, bringing her performing career full circle back to live classical theatre.

Ansel Elgort’s Work in Television

Following West Side Story, Elgort focused primarily on long-form television drama rather than major theatrical studio musicals:

  • Tokyo Vice (2022–2024): Elgort starred as real-life journalist Jake Adelstein in the critically praised Max crime drama series executive produced by Michael Mann. For the role, Elgort undertook intensive Japanese language training and martial arts preparation, receiving favorable reviews for his dedicated dramatic performance across its two seasons.

Key Takeaways for Film & Theatre Enthusiasts

  1. Vocal Integrity: Unlike the 1961 film, both Elgort and Zegler performed their own singing voices, utilizing extensive live recording techniques on set overseen by Jeanine Tesori.
  2. Authentic Representation: Zegler was chosen through an open international search of over 30,000 applicants, marking a major industry shift toward authentic Hispanic and Latinx casting in musical theatre cinema.
  3. Character Realism: Tony Kushner’s script grounded Elgort’s Tony with a violent prison backstory and Zegler’s María with economic independence at Gimbels, shifting their romance from fairy-tale idealism toward grounded drama.
  4. Ensemble Dynamics: Critical evaluation of the 2021 film noted that while Zegler earned top acting honors, the explosive energy of supporting performers Mike Faist and Ariana DeBose often dominated the screen dynamic.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Ansel Elgort and Rachel Zegler actually sing in West Side Story?

Yes. Both Ansel Elgort and Rachel Zegler sang all of their own musical parts in the 2021 film. Under the direction of supervisor Jeanine Tesori, the production utilized a combination of live vocals recorded directly on set and studio-recorded tracks, ensuring that physical breath work and emotional delivery matched their movements.

How old were Ansel Elgort and Rachel Zegler when filming West Side Story?

During principal photography (which took place between July and September 2019), Rachel Zegler was 18 years old, having been cast when she was 17. Ansel Elgort was 25 years old during filming.

How was Rachel Zegler discovered for the role of María?

Rachel Zegler was discovered through an open casting call in early 2018. She submitted a self-taped video of herself singing "Tonight" and "Me Siento Extraña" ("I Feel Pretty"). Out of more than 30,000 global applicants, Zegler was selected after nearly a year of callbacks and screen tests.

What awards did Rachel Zegler win for West Side Story?

Rachel Zegler won the Golden Globe Award for Best Actress – Motion Picture Comedy or Musical at the 79th Golden Globe Awards, becoming the youngest winner in that category at age 20. She also won the National Board of Review Award for Best Actress.

Why was Tony’s backstory changed for Ansel Elgort in the 2021 version?

Screenwriter Tony Kushner wanted to give Tony a plausible reason for rejecting gang violence. In the 2021 film, Tony has just completed a one-year prison sentence at Sing Sing for nearly killing a rival gang member. This change makes his desire for peace concrete and explains his initial reluctance to participate in the rumble.

Who sang for Tony and María in the original 1961 West Side Story movie?

In the 1961 film version, neither lead sang their own songs. Natalie Wood’s singing voice as María was dubbed by playback singer Marni Nixon, while Richard Beymer’s singing voice as Tony was dubbed by Jimmy Bryant.