Anthony D’Amico and Ashley Petta remain one of the most successful and enduring couples in the history of the Married at First Sight (MAFS) franchise. Since their television debut in 2017, the Chicago-based couple has transitioned from reality TV participants to a stable, growing family, successfully navigating the challenges of marriage, parenthood, and public life.
The Foundation of a Reality TV Success Story
When Anthony D’Amico and Ashley Petta were matched for Season 5 of Married at First Sight, the series was still establishing its reputation as a social experiment. Filmed in Chicago and airing in 2017, their season sought to prove that clinical matching could lead to long-term marital success. From their first meeting at the altar, the chemistry between the two was palpable, a rarity in a show often characterized by awkward first encounters and immediate friction.
Ashley, who worked in her family’s bar and grill, came to the experiment with a clear vision: she wanted a partner who was ready for a serious commitment and, eventually, a family. Anthony, a sales professional with a charismatic personality, was looking for a deep connection that had eluded him in the traditional dating world. Their compatibility was grounded in shared values, specifically their Italian-American heritage and a strong emphasis on family ties.
The Initial Attraction and On-Screen Chemistry
Unlike many other couples in the franchise, Anthony and Ashley experienced a relatively smooth honeymoon period. Their trip to the Bahamas showcased a natural rapport that suggested they had known each other for years rather than days. However, the experiment is designed to test couples through the "real-world" transition, which for them included moving into a shared apartment in Chicago and navigating each other's social circles and professional lives.
One of the most notable aspects of their early relationship was their ability to communicate through disagreements. While they faced hurdles—such as Ashley’s desire to start a family immediately versus Anthony’s preference for a more gradual approach—they avoided the explosive arguments that often plague reality TV marriages. Their conflict resolution style was characterized by honesty and, occasionally, a stubbornness that both partners eventually learned to manage.
Decision Day and the Post-Show Transition
On Decision Day, the conclusion of the eight-week experiment, the choice for Anthony and Ashley was unanimous: they both chose to stay married. This decision was not a surprise to viewers, but the true test began once the cameras stopped rolling. The transition from a televised marriage to a private life is often where MAFS couples fail, yet Anthony and Ashley used this period to solidify their bond away from the constant scrutiny of production.
They eventually moved from their initial shared apartment into a more permanent home, balancing their careers while maintaining their presence in the Married at First Sight universe. Their success led to their inclusion in several spin-offs, including Married at First Sight: Happily Ever After? and the self-filmed Married at First Sight: Couples’ Cam. These programs provided fans with a window into their lives as they navigated the complexities of long-term partnership.
Navigating Career and Public Identity
As the couple’s popularity grew, so did their influence on social media. Anthony and Ashley have managed their public personas with a level of authenticity that has kept their fanbase loyal through 2026. While many reality stars pivot entirely to "influencing," the D'Amicos have maintained a balance. Ashley continued to be involved with her family’s business interests, while Anthony utilized his background in sales and marketing to navigate the digital landscape.
Their ability to remain "relatable" has been a key factor in their longevity. They frequently share the unvarnished reality of marriage—tired mornings, toddler tantrums, and the effort required to keep a relationship fresh after a decade together. This transparency has made them the "gold standard" for what the Married at First Sight experts (Dr. Pepper Schwartz and Pastor Calvin Roberson) hope to achieve with every match.
Building a Family: Mila and Vaeda
The most significant milestones in Anthony and Ashley’s journey have been the births of their two daughters. For Ashley, motherhood was a primary goal from the moment she entered the experiment, and seeing that dream realized within her marriage has been a central theme of their public narrative.
The Arrival of Mila Rose
In January 2019, the couple welcomed their first daughter, Mila Rose D’Amico. Mila’s birth was a landmark moment for the franchise, as she was one of the first children born to a couple from the U.S. version of the show who remained together. Her arrival was documented through social media and special segments on Lifetime, allowing fans who had watched Anthony and Ashley’s wedding to see their family grow.
The transition to parenthood brought new challenges. Like many first-time parents, they dealt with sleep deprivation and the shift in relationship dynamics that a newborn necessitates. However, they were vocal about the support they provided one another, with Anthony often praised by fans for his hands-on approach to fatherhood.
Expanding the Family with Vaeda Marie
In February 2021, the family grew again with the birth of their second daughter, Vaeda Marie D’Amico. The experience of having two children under the age of three during a period of global transition tested their resilience. Ashley shared her experiences with pregnancy and postpartum life openly, discussing the physical and emotional toll it takes, which further endeared her to a demographic of mothers and young families.
By 2026, Mila and Vaeda have become central figures in the couple’s life. Their growth and milestones are a testament to the stable environment Anthony and Ashley have built. The couple often emphasizes that while they met in an unconventional way, their day-to-day life is remarkably traditional, centered around school runs, family dinners, and holiday traditions in the Chicago area.
Why the Anthony and Ashley Match Worked
Analyzing their success provides insight into the psychological and social factors that contribute to a lasting marriage. While many MAFS matches fail due to fundamental incompatibilities or a lack of commitment to the process, Anthony and Ashley possessed several key traits:
- Shared Life Stages: Both entered the experiment truly ready for marriage. They were not looking for fame or a temporary experience; they were looking for a life partner.
- Cultural Compatibility: Their shared Italian-American backgrounds gave them a common language regarding family expectations, food, and social traditions.
- Communication Skills: Even when they disagreed—specifically regarding the timeline for children or where to live—they remained committed to the conversation until a compromise was reached.
- Resilience to Public Pressure: They have successfully filtered out the "noise" of social media criticism, focusing instead on their internal relationship and the well-being of their children.
| Milestone | Date | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Wedding Day | August 2016 | Married at First Sight Season 5 (Chicago) |
| Decision Day | October 2016 | Chose to stay married after the 8-week experiment |
| Season 5 Premiere | April 2017 | Introduced to the public on Lifetime |
| Mila Rose Born | January 2019 | First child; solidified their status as a success story |
| Vaeda Marie Born | February 2021 | Second child; expanded their growing family |
| 10-Year Anniversary | August 2026 | Celebrating a decade of marriage since the experiment |
Anthony and Ashley’s Impact on the MAFS Franchise
In the broader context of reality television, Anthony and Ashley serve as a vital data point for the "success rate" of televised matchmaking. As the franchise has expanded into dozens of seasons across various cities, their story is frequently cited by the experts as proof that the process works when the participants are sincere.
They have appeared as mentors for newer couples, offering advice on how to handle the "pressure cooker" environment of the first few weeks of marriage. Their advice typically focuses on looking past the cameras and treating the marriage as a real-life commitment rather than a TV role. As of 2026, they remain one of the few couples from the early seasons of the show to stay married, placing them in an exclusive group that includes Jamie Otis and Doug Hehner (Season 1).
Current Life in 2026
As of 2026, Anthony and Ashley continue to reside in the Chicago area. Their life is a blend of suburban stability and the occasional public appearance. They have successfully avoided the "reality TV curse" by prioritizing their private relationship over public attention.
For those following their journey, the couple represents hope in an era of digital dating. They are active on platforms like Instagram, where they provide updates on their home renovations, their daughters' school milestones, and their own personal growth. While they are no longer the "new" couple on the block, their enduring presence provides a sense of continuity for the Married at First Sight audience.
The Role of Social Media in 2026
In 2026, the D'Amicos utilize their platform to partner with brands that align with their family-centric values. This includes home goods, children's products, and travel-related content. However, they have been careful to set boundaries, ensuring that their children’s privacy is respected while still sharing the joy of their family life. This balanced approach to "sharenting" has been lauded by child safety advocates and fans alike.
Key Takeaways from Their Marriage
- Commitment to the Process: They didn't just sign up for a show; they signed up for a marriage. This distinction is what separates successful MAFS couples from those who divorce shortly after filming.
- Adaptability: Both Anthony and Ashley have shown a willingness to change. Anthony embraced the role of a father with enthusiasm, and Ashley learned to navigate Anthony’s need for logic and timing.
- Maintaining Identity: They have remained "Anthony and Ashley from Chicago" rather than becoming caricatures of reality TV stars.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Anthony and Ashley still together in 2026?
Yes, Anthony D’Amico and Ashley Petta are still married as of 2026. They recently celebrated their tenth wedding anniversary, having originally married in August 2016 during the filming of Season 5. They remain one of the longest-standing and most successful couples in the history of the Married at First Sight franchise.
How many children do Anthony and Ashley have?
The couple has two daughters. Their first daughter, Mila Rose, was born in January 2019. Their second daughter, Vaeda Marie, followed in February 2021. Both children have occasionally appeared on Married at First Sight spin-offs and are frequently featured on the couple’s social media channels.
Which season of Married at First Sight were they on?
Anthony and Ashley were featured on Season 5 of Married at First Sight, which was based in Chicago, Illinois. The season originally aired on the Lifetime network in 2017. They were the only couple from that specific season to remain married long-term.
What do Anthony and Ashley do for a living now?
While both have a significant social media presence as influencers within the parenting and lifestyle niches, they have maintained ties to their original professional interests. Ashley has long been involved in her family’s restaurant business in Chicago, while Anthony has worked in sales and media marketing.
Where do Anthony and Ashley live?
The D'Amico family lives in the Chicago, Illinois area. They have often shared glimpses of their home and their life in the suburbs on social media, emphasizing their roots in the Midwest and their proximity to their extended family.
Final Recommendation for Fans
If you are looking to follow the most authentic success story of the Married at First Sight franchise, following Anthony and Ashley on their official social media platforms is the best way to stay updated. Their journey serves as a practical guide for how to maintain a healthy, communicative marriage under the unique pressure of public life. For those interested in the psychological aspects of their match, re-watching Season 5 or their segments in Couples' Cam on Lifetime provides deep insight into how they built their foundation.