Skip to content
Entertainment & Biography

Anthony Carrigan in The Forgotten: A Career-Defining Early Role

In this article

Anthony Carrigan’s portrayal of Tyler Davies in the 2009 television series The Forgotten served as a critical foundation for his trajectory into Hollywood stardom. While many modern audiences recognize him for his transformative work in Barry or his 2025 debut as Metamorpho, this procedural drama established his range as a nuanced dramatic actor.

In the landscape of 2026, looking back at the early career of Anthony Carrigan reveals a fascinating evolution. Long before he became a household name for his Emmy-nominated comedy and high-profile superhero roles, Carrigan was a standout in a short-lived but emotionally resonant crime procedural titled The Forgotten. Produced by Jerry Bruckheimer and airing on ABC from 2009 to 2010, the series placed Carrigan in a central ensemble cast that tackled the grim reality of unidentified victims. To understand the actor Carrigan has become, one must analyze the significance of his role as Tyler Davies—a character that required a blend of technical precision, artistic sensitivity, and burgeoning screen presence.

Understanding the Premise of The Forgotten

To appreciate Carrigan’s contribution, it is essential to contextualize the series itself. The Forgotten was built on a unique hook within the crowded "police procedural" genre of the late 2000s. Instead of focusing on elite detectives or forensic scientists with unlimited budgets, the show centered on "The Forgotten Network"—a group of dedicated civilian volunteers.

The team’s mission was to identify "John and Jane Does"—victims of homicides whose identities remained a mystery, often leading their cases to go cold. The show utilized a poignant narrative device where the victim would provide a voice-over, narrating their own post-mortem journey as the volunteers pieced together the fragments of their lives. This emotional weight demanded a cast that could project empathy and determination without the shield of a badge or a laboratory.

The Role of Tyler Davies

Anthony Carrigan played Tyler Davies, a talented sculptor and medical school dropout. His character was not merely a civilian investigator; he was the "artist" of the group. Tyler’s specific skill set involved forensic reconstruction—using his sculpting abilities to recreate the faces of victims from their skeletal remains.

This role was significant for several reasons:

  1. Technical Complexity: Carrigan had to portray a character burdened by the guilt of dropping out of medical school while utilizing those same anatomical skills to serve the dead.
  2. Emotional Anchor: As the youngest member of the core team (which included veteran actors like Christian Slater), Carrigan provided a "rookie" perspective that allowed the audience to learn the stakes of the work alongside him.
  3. Visual Storytelling: Much of Tyler’s work was silent and focused. Carrigan’s ability to convey internal thought processes through facial expressions and precise movements—skills he would later master in Barry—was already evident here.

Anthony Carrigan’s Performance and Character Dynamics

In The Forgotten, the chemistry between the volunteers was the engine of the show. Carrigan’s Tyler Davies acted as a bridge between the weary leadership of Alex Donovan (Christian Slater) and the more clinical approach of other team members.

The Artistic Sensibility

Tyler Davies was written with a specific kind of sensitivity. Unlike the hardened detectives found in CSI or Law & Order, Tyler was frequently affected by the stories of the victims. Carrigan brought a palpable vulnerability to the role. In 2026, critics often point to this period as the moment Carrigan proved he could lead a dramatic ensemble.

His background in theater helped him navigate the procedural's dialogue, which often required explaining complex forensic concepts while maintaining an emotional connection to the case. Tyler’s journey through the first (and only) season involved reconciling his failed aspirations in medicine with his newfound purpose, providing a substantial character arc that Carrigan handled with maturity beyond his years.

Transitioning Archetypes

At the time of The Forgotten, Anthony Carrigan possessed a full head of hair and a more conventional "leading man" look. It is a period of his career that stands in stark contrast to his later, more iconic appearances. However, the intensity he brought to the screen remained constant. Even in 2009, there was an edge to his performance that suggested he was more than a typical television protagonist. He resisted the urge to play Tyler as a generic "hot young doctor" type, instead leaning into the character’s frustrations and his obsessive need to get the "reconstruction" exactly right.

Anthony Carrigan says alopecia has made him a better actor
Anthony Carrigan says alopecia has made him a better actor

Technical Specifications and Production Context

The Forgotten was a high-gloss production typical of the Jerry Bruckheimer television era. Despite its pedigree, it faced a difficult uphill battle regarding ratings and network placement.

Feature Details
Network ABC
Creator Mark Friedman
Executive Producer Jerry Bruckheimer
Original Run September 22, 2009 – July 3, 2010
Total Episodes 17
Primary Cast Christian Slater, Anthony Carrigan, Michelle Borth, Bob Stephenson
Carrigan's Character Tyler Davies
Character Profession Sculptor / Med School Dropout

The show’s cancellation after one season is often attributed to the oversaturation of the procedural market at the time. However, for Carrigan, the 17 episodes of The Forgotten provided a masterclass in television production. He worked alongside seasoned professionals, navigating the rigorous shooting schedules and high stakes of a major network drama. This experience undoubtedly prepared him for the more complex tonal shifts of his future work.

The Evolution of Carrigan’s Craft: From Tyler to NoHo Hank

Analyzing Anthony Carrigan’s work in The Forgotten provides a clear lineage to his later success. While Tyler Davies was a relatively "straight" dramatic role, the seeds of Carrigan’s unique physicality were sown there.

Physical Acting

In The Forgotten, Carrigan used his hands and his posture to define Tyler’s identity as an artist. There is a specific grace in how he handles sculpting tools in the series that mirrors the meticulous way he would later handle props as Victor Zsasz in Gotham or the expressive, almost dance-like gestures of NoHo Hank in Barry.

Vulnerability as a Strength

One of the hallmarks of a "Carrigan performance" is a surprising level of vulnerability in characters who might otherwise be one-dimensional. In The Forgotten, Tyler’s vulnerability came from his perceived failures. In Barry, NoHo Hank’s vulnerability came from his desperate desire for friendship and validation. By the time he reached the height of his fame in the mid-2020s, Carrigan had perfected this "vulnerable outsider" archetype, a journey that arguably began with Tyler Davies.

The Impact of Alopecia on Carrigan’s Career Path

It is impossible to discuss Anthony Carrigan’s career without mentioning his journey with alopecia areata. During the filming of The Forgotten, Carrigan was already experiencing hair loss, though it was largely managed or less advanced than in his later roles.

Carrigan has been vocal in interviews about the fear he felt during this stage of his career—worrying that his changing appearance would end his opportunities in an industry obsessed with a specific standard of beauty. His role in The Forgotten represents the final chapter of his "conventional" casting before he fully embraced his look. This transition ultimately became his superpower, allowing him to step into roles that required a striking, unique presence. In 2026, he is celebrated as a pioneer for actors with visible differences, but The Forgotten remains a testament to the fact that his talent was undeniable regardless of his physical appearance.

Why The Forgotten Still Matters in 2026

For fans of Carrigan and television historians, The Forgotten serves as more than just a footnote. It is a snapshot of a specific era of television where the "Bruckheimer procedural" was the gold standard.

A Study in Ensemble Dynamics

The show remains a strong example of how to build a diverse team of characters with distinct motivations. Tyler Davies wasn't just "the young guy"; he was the moral compass who often reminded the group that the skeletal remains on their table were once living, breathing people with dreams. This humanistic approach to crime drama has seen a resurgence in the mid-2020s, making The Forgotten feel surprisingly modern upon rewatch.

Availability and Legacy

In 2026, The Forgotten can occasionally be found on niche streaming services or through digital purchase on platforms like Amazon Prime Video or Apple TV. While it did not achieve the multi-season longevity of CSI or Bones, its legacy lives on through the careers of its cast.

For Anthony Carrigan, the show was a proof of concept. It proved he could hold his own against a star like Christian Slater. It proved he could handle the technical jargon of a specialized role. And most importantly, it proved he had the "it factor" that would eventually lead him to the Marvel and DC cinematic universes.

Comparisons to Other Early Roles

Before and shortly after The Forgotten, Carrigan appeared in other projects that rounded out his early filmography. Comparing these helps highlight why The Forgotten was his most significant early TV role.

  • Parenthood (2011): Carrigan had a brief guest spot. While a popular show, it didn't offer the character depth provided by Tyler Davies.
  • Long Island Confidential (2008): An early TV movie that showed his potential but lacked the wide reach of a Jerry Bruckheimer production.
  • The Undying (2011): A thriller that allowed him to explore darker themes, bridging the gap between his role in The Forgotten and his eventual casting as Victor Zsasz.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was Anthony Carrigan the lead in The Forgotten?

Anthony Carrigan was part of the primary ensemble cast. While Christian Slater was the top-billed star, Carrigan’s character, Tyler Davies, was a central figure in every episode and often handled the "forensic reconstruction" sequences that were a signature of the show.

Why was The Forgotten cancelled after only one season?

The show suffered from middling ratings in a highly competitive Tuesday night timeslot. Additionally, ABC was moving away from traditional procedurals at the time, opting for more serialized dramas. Despite its cancellation, the show maintains a small cult following today in 2026.

How did Anthony Carrigan get the role of Tyler Davies?

Carrigan was cast after a rigorous pilot season. His background in professional theater and his ability to project both intelligence and vulnerability made him a perfect fit for the "med school dropout" archetype that the creators were looking for.

Did Anthony Carrigan have alopecia during the filming of The Forgotten?

Yes, Carrigan has stated that he was dealing with alopecia during the show's production. In some episodes, the effects were managed with makeup or were simply less pronounced than they would become in later years. He has since become a prominent advocate for the alopecia community.

Where can I watch The Forgotten in 2026?

Currently, The Forgotten is available for purchase on most major digital storefronts, including IMDb and various secondary streaming platforms. Due to licensing agreements, it is not always available on "Big Three" streamers (Netflix, Disney+, Max) but can often be found on ad-supported services like Tubi or Freevee.

Final Recommendation: A Must-Watch for Carrigan Completionists

If you are a fan of Anthony Carrigan's modern work, seeking out The Forgotten is a highly rewarding endeavor. It offers a rare look at the actor in a traditional dramatic role, showcasing the foundational skills that he would later subvert and expand upon in his more famous characters.

The series itself remains a touching, if somber, exploration of identity and the importance of being remembered. In an era where Carrigan is playing larger-than-life characters like Metamorpho, seeing him as the quiet, artistic Tyler Davies serves as a reminder of his incredible range and the steady work he put in to become one of the most respected actors of his generation.